All methods emerge from a methodology.
A methodology is a philosophy of method. A methodology is NOT a method. (https://www.uwa.edu.au/students/-/media/project/uwa/uwa/students/docs/studysmarter/hm4-methods-and-methdology.pdf)
Those who confuse the two, demonstrate that they don’t know the difference. Similarly, with those who confuse ethics and morals (AIHS BoK) or those who confuse slogans as principles.
A methodology (philosophy) includes a declared position on: ethics, values, principles, ontology (being), beliefs, assumptions, theory of human personhood and knowing.
Whether these are articulated clearly or not doesn’t mean they are not there.
Many in risk and safety present methods but not the driving methodology underneath that method (or slogan). This is very common in incident investigation methods (https://www.humandymensions.com/product/seek-investigations-a-semiotic-method/ ). For example, the methodology hidden under zero ideology is a philosophy of perfectionism and the denial of fallibility. This is why Zero promotes delusion (https://www.humandymensions.com/product/zero-the-great-safety-delusion/).
A philosophy is easily detected in the choice of language, slogans, rituals, myths and symbols.
For example. If you chose the symbol of swiss-cheese as your method for investigations you hide a linear methodology about being and living. If you chose the bow-tie a similar assumption of in and out is believed. These models are all left-right in orientation which is the same for Fishbone.
These symbols/models assume an ordered and systematic approach to knowing, and don’t entertain any sense of risk as a wicked problem (https://safetyrisk.net/safety-wicked-problem/). (One of the global experts on wicked problems is Dr Craig Ashhurst who is on the SPoR team.)
The reality is that life is not ordered and systematic but rather: messy, unpredictable, non-linear, brittle, fragile, incomprehensible, volatile and ambiguous (https://safetyrisk.net/safety-investigations-are-they-vuca-bani-or-wicked/). If we are going to use symbols in safety, they should reflect this reality.
BTW, there are valid philosophies/methodologies other than the dominant philosophies adopted by Safety
HOP Symbols and Slogans
When we observe the slogans and symbols of choice in HOP, we see an undisclosed methodology that assumes: linear causation, brain-centred cognition, systems-focus fixing, demonising blame yet at the same time asserting fallibility, a materialist understanding of social being, reductionism, dis-embodied and linear causality.
Please note: It’s not that some of the slogans presented in HOP are bad in themselves. Some are good but some are dangerous and promote significant conflict/problems legally and operationally.
Example 1. Look at the central symbolism of HOP and its brain-centric. Indeed, the image of a brain growing in a pot tells us that learning is understood as getting data into a brain. Indeed, the language of mind and brain are used interchangeably! This tells us that a HOP view of learning is about brain cognition NOT about holistic enactive being. So, the word ‘learning’ in HOP means data transfer/training and brain-centric decision making. This also implies an ethic of learning/being that is dis-embodied and NOT enactive or embodied.
Example 2. The use of Jenga blocks and mice, is linear and based on the same model of prevention as the swiss-cheese as proposed by Reason fifty years ago. The model is similar the domino logic presented by Heinrich 100 years ago. The principle of causality is the same as traditional safety (systemic, linear, up-down, ordered and predictable).
We can see how the symbols of HOP are attractive to safety because they pose no new paradigm (worldview/philosophy) and reinforce traditional paradigms, with new slogans and symbols.
Example 3. By calling slogans ‘principles’ we see how the underlying ethics in HOP are hidden. Something is NOT a principle if it is a contradiction or demonstrably false.
This is simple to demonstrate with the slogan ‘blame fixes nothing’ or the slogan ‘context drives behaviour’.
Indeed, in HOP it is clear that the belief is: that if you blame systems rather than people, everything can be fixed. So, blame fixes things.
Similarly, there are many factors that are beyond context that drive behaviour. Any anthropological or religious study of First Nations peoples demonstrates this.
Example 4. It is clear that HOP slogans and symbols are popular but once the entertainment has died down, it can’t be operationalised. Methods are best when they emerge from a clearly defined methodology.
So, in the end, it becomes a case of how to integrate a collection of slogans and aspirations into standardised traditional safety systems. This need not be bad but it is not a ‘new view’ of safety.
Even when a HOP Nerd tries to articulate some sense of operability (https://www.thehopnerd.com/post/hop-implementation-a-brief-guiding-to-getting-started-with-human-organizational-performance) it’s all the same things Safety has been doing for years. Again, it’s not that these are bad, it’s just they are not ‘different’ or ‘new’.
When you look at HOP symbols of operational-ability (https://havensafety.com/hop-learning-teams-safety.html ) it’s two people with clip boards looking at a head. There is no method to operationalise and its symbolically brain-centric and dis-embodied.
If we look at this model of how one operationalises HOP (https://havensafety.com/hop-learning-teams-safety.html), it’s about systems controls, system aspirations with the work-as-done vs work-as-imagined myth (https://safetyrisk.net/the-work-as-imagined-and-work-as-done-scam/).
In none of this is there any discussion of human personhood even though the word ‘human’ is its descriptive adjective.
What is presented as operationalised HOP is what Safety has been doing for years. We even see these so called ‘principles’ being called a ‘philosophy’. There is no declaration of a philosophy/methodology in any of this. A collection of aspirations is not a philosophy.
These are a collection of aspirations NOT a method.
Note Again: It’s not that these aspirations are bad but rather that these are not principles or a philosophy. Indeed, the philosophy remains hidden in the symbols and slogans.
So, then we observe that HOP is now all safety theories wrapped into 5 slogans. Somehow, all of this will improve the way we work. Nothing involves any evidence or argument about fundamental principles or beliefs one would read in a founding methodology/philosophy. Nor, is there any evidence or research for what this semiotic claims.
Whilst you will read a lot about ‘doing’ in HOP and safety differently, doing requires a methodology and method. So, it’s back to systems with a few new aspirations.
This has been described by some as ‘HOP-washing’
So, when we look at the trends and evolution of language and discourse in safety, what do we see? Has there been any fundamental shift in philosophy/methodology? Do the new symbols and slogans offer anything different than has been proposed before? If they do, it would great to see some evidence/research that demonstrates some philosophical/methodological movement. Iy would be good to see that methodology named and articulated.
You can watch Episode 9 of safety semiotics here: https://vimeo.com/showcase/12476053
brhttps://safetyrisk.net/how-symbols-and-slogans-hide-methodology-safety-semiotics-episode-9-hop-symbols/
Prompt